All cars will lose money over time and their value can be determined by a range of factors according to market demand. But which car makes and models suffer the highest annual depreciation rate overall?

A new study from GAP Insurance provider, ALA Insurance has crunched the data on new and used cars to reveal which hold their value better than others.

Using new and used car data for 47 of the most popular and reliable vehicles on the market, the research confirms that the Audi Q4 e-tron has the highest annual depreciation rate of any other car.

Introduced in March 2021, the German-manufactured Q4 e-tron is the fourth fully-electric model in the Audi e-tron series and depreciates in value by 18.1% annually.

Close behind the e-tron sits two of the market’s other most popular electric vehicles, the Volkswagen ID. 3 and the Jaguar I-Pace which depreciate at 17.8% and 17.3% every year, respectively.

The accelerated rate of electric vehicle depreciation has become a hot topic this year with some experts deeming their widespread loss in value unsustainable. So it’s no surprise to see three of the sectors most prized models comprise the top three for worst value in return. ALA’s data further supports the issue of electric vehicle depreciation with fully electric models seeing an average annual value loss of 14% while other fuel vehicles sit at 11.9%.

At the other end of the scale it was the Cupra Formentor which sits as the best investment on the market losing only 2.5% of its value annually. In second place overall sits the BMW i4 which only depreciates at 3.1% making it the best all electric model on the market for return on investment.

The Land Rover Defender sits comfortably as the car with the third lowest depreciation rate of 6.3%. With a high resale value Defenders remain a solid investment with their timeless, iconic design and durability.

ALA’s study also ranks the best and worst performing car makes with Volkswagen’s average yearly value loss at just 10.9% compared to Nissan at 14.2%.

Naturally new vehicles are subject to a faster depreciation after purchase, however,  the data shows that selling a car at the four year mark will yield the best return as average value loss sits at 9% compared to 14.6% in its third year and 10.7% in its fifth.

Speaking on the study, ALA Insurance Founder and Managing Director, Simon England says:

“We wanted to dig deeper on car value retention of some of the market’s most popular makes and models to help motorists make more informed decisions when it comes to purchasing their next car. While there are measures you can take to help your car retain its value like regular servicing, avoiding excessive mileage and more, car depreciation will always occur and it’s worth being aware of.

“In the event your car is written off or stolen, GAP Insurance is critical to make sure you retain your car’s full value, despite any market depreciation. This is especially important when it comes to cars with low value retention, so if your car is one of the models identified in our study it could be worth exploring your options.”

Annual depreciation rates of UK models

Make

Model

Av. Yearly Value Loss

Cupra

Formentor

2.5%

BMW

i4

3.1%

Land Rover

Defender

6.3%

MG

HS

7.9%

Volkswagen

Golf

8.8%

Jaguar

F-Type

8.9%

Volkswagen

T-Roc

9.2%

Tesla

Model X

9.3%

Ford

Puma

9.4%

Lexus

NX

9.6%

Kia

Sportage

9.8%

Mercedes-Benz

S-Class

10.1%

Toyota

Yaris

10.6%

Audi

A3

10.7%

Jaguar

E-Pace

10.9%

Range Rover

Velar

11.0%

Mercedes-Benz

C-Class

11.3%

Land Rover

Discovery

11.4%

Jaguar

XJR

11.4%

Mercedes-Benz

GLA-Class

11.5%

Lexus

UX

11.8%

Kia

e-Niro

12.0%

Nissan

Juke

12.2%

Audi

RS6

12.3%

BMW

X1

12.3%

Mercedes-Benz

A-Class

12.3%

Tesla

Model 3

12.7%

Land Rover

Evoque

12.9%

BMW

M3

13.0%

Nissan

Qashqai

13.1%

Tesla

Model Y

13.2%

Land Rover

Discovery Sport

13.8%

BMW

X3

13.9%

Hyundai

Tucson

14.1%

BMW

3 Series

14.5%

Range Rover

Sport

14.8%

BMW

1 Series

14.9%

Audi

A7

15.0%

Mini

Electric

15.0%

Vauxhall

Mokka Electric

15.1%

Mercedes-Benz

E-Class

15.3%

BMW

5 Series

15.8%

Tesla

Model S

17.1%

Nissan

Leaf

17.2%

Jaguar

I-Pace

17.3%

Volkswagen

ID. 3

17.8%

Audi

Q4 e-tron

18.1%

To learn more about how GAP Insurance can protect you visit the ALA Insurance website.